Another tunnel needs to do it.
Photo: Miami Herald/Tribune News Service by means of Getty Images

Last weekend, Elon Musk declared that he ‘d had a conversation with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis about his Boring Company task, which develops really brief, very small tunnels for cars. “Cars & trucks stuck in traffic create megatons of hazardous gases & particulate, however @boringcompany roadway tunnels under Miami would resolve traffic & be an example to the world,” he tweeted.

Now prior to we write this off yet another example of Musk’s perpetual grift of making empty guarantees to city leaders that are amplified by his 42.6 million followers, let’s consider that there might be a reason Miami doesn’t have a train. Or why a lot of its homes are built without basements. Or why the city has already spent numerous countless dollars simply to make its streets accessible to automobiles today— building a pump system to reduce the flooding Miami now deals with even when no storms are on the horizon.

” It’s the sinkhole capital of the United States, let’s begin with there,” says Mika McKinnon, a field geophysicist and catastrophe scientist based in Vancouver. The ground below Miami is an extremely dissolvable limestone karst that’s filled with cavities and caverns similar to the sea floor. “If you want to have a tunnel, you need to pump the water out of the tunnel as you go,” she states. “And when you struck a cavern or you puncture a cavity, it alters the pressure. It’s like popping your cars and truck into neutral while you’re on the highway.” There are tunnels in Miami, however they’re astronomically pricey– the Port of Miami built less than a mile of tunnel below a shallow channel for about $1 billion– and cheaper tunneling is the thrust of Musk’s undertaking (although whether or not the Boring Company has actually genuinely been able to cut tunneling expenses is still up for dispute). However the most significant concern is presenting the threat of collapse to what lies above. “I ‘d be asking what their legal liability plan is,” says McKinnon. “Since part of the concern with the changing of the water table is that it won’t be a direct cause and effect — 30 blocks away is what is going to sink. This is not a practical task without sinkholes, so what will they do when they get taken legal action against?” It’s quite possible Musk has convinced DeSantis that he’s considered all that. Or maybe he’s making the whole conversation up; keep in mind when he declared to have “spoken approval” for a hyperloop tunnel from New york city City to D.C.?

Part of the inspiration behind Suarez’s sycophancy may be that he’s attempting to reinvent Miami as a tech paradise by charming remote-working founders newly untethered from corporate campuses. Musk’s arrival would be yet another selling tool to lure start-ups far from Silicon Valley. But a strategy to inundate the city with more residents at this specific minute also features serious issues, notes McKinnon. “Miami is probably among the most vulnerable cities for sea-level rise,” she states. “It’s a lost city. It’s a zombie city. Purchasing coastal residential or commercial property in Miami resembles tossing your cash into the ocean.” By 2100 it’s estimated that a large portion of Miami-Dade County will be rendered uninhabitable by approximately 5 feet of rising ocean. Almost one million citizens are likely to be displaced.

However let’s pretend, for a minute, that Musk, who claims to want to resolve the issue of climate modification, does understand the standard science behind it. Now he’s marketing false hopes for stopping climate change to a city that’s already suffering the extremely worst repercussions of this future? It’s the transport equivalent of building high-end towers high above the threat of sea-level increase while leaving the remainder of the population to drown. Which is precisely what Miami is doing.

There may lastly be a light at the end of this tunnel. The Boring Company’s rise was straight allowed by the Trump administration, especially when Musk got his tunnels name-checked as one of the “transformative”– read: speculative bullshit– tasks that would get $20 billion in federal funding in the statements for a never-realized facilities strategy. This was followed by former Transportation secretary Elaine Chao’s extremely targeted loosening of policies around those so-called emerging innovations “such as possible advances in tunneling technology and hyperloop.” Joe Biden’s incoming Transportation administration (hi, soon-to-be-confirmed Secretary Pete!) must train a close eye on how Musk is utilizing his power– and, recently, substantial earnings– to make what are already really major problems for cities even worse.

Elon Musk’s Miami Tunnel Plan Is Filled With Holes